How to reply to a one star review

The reply is not for the person who wrote the review. They have made their mind up and they are not coming back.

The reply is for the next forty people who read it while deciding whether to ring you. That is the whole game. Once you accept that, most of the hard decisions get easy.

Wait a day

Nothing good has ever been written in the twenty minutes after you read a one star review. Draft it if you need to get it out of your system, then leave it in a notes app overnight.

Nobody has ever lost a customer because a reply landed on Tuesday instead of Monday. Plenty have lost customers because of what they wrote on Monday.

What a good reply looks like

Four parts, in this order, and short.

1. Thanks or acknowledgement. One line. Not grovelling.
2. The facts, if they matter. Calm, brief, no argument.
3. What you did or will do. This is the bit the next reader is actually looking for.
4. A way to take it offline. A name and a phone number or email.

Under a hundred words. Long replies read as defensive no matter how reasonable the words are.

And use a human name. "Thanks Sarah, Luke here" beats "Dear valued customer" every single time.

Three templates

1. The complaint is fair

You stuffed it up. This is the easiest one to reply to and the one people avoid.

Thanks for the feedback, Mark, and sorry. You booked for Tuesday and we did not turn up until Thursday, and that is on us. We were short two staff that week and we should have called you instead of leaving you waiting. We have changed how we handle reschedules so it does not happen again. If you would like me to sort out the job, give me a ring on 02 XXXX XXXX. Luke.

Why it works: it names the specific failure, it does not hide behind "circumstances", and it tells the next reader exactly what changed. An owner who owns a mistake in public reads better than an owner with no bad reviews at all.

2. You disagree with it

Genuine customer, honest experience, but their account is not how you saw it. This is the one where people get themselves into trouble.

Thanks for taking the time, Sarah. I am sorry it did not go the way you wanted. Our record shows the quote was sent on 3 June and the work was scheduled for the following week, so I think there may have been a mix-up somewhere. I would rather sort it out than argue about it here. I am on 02 XXXX XXXX any weekday if you would like to talk it through. Luke.

Why it works: one factual correction, delivered flatly, then the door opens. No sarcasm, no "as I explained on the phone", no listing every way they are wrong. The next reader is judging your temperament, not adjudicating the dispute.

3. It is not a real customer

Wrong business, competitor, someone who has never been near you.

We have looked through our records and cannot find a booking or job under this name, so we think this review may have been left for another business. Happy to be wrong. If we have worked together, please ring me on 02 XXXX XXXX and I will sort it out. Luke.

Why it works: it states the position without accusing anyone of anything. Publicly calling someone a fraud reads badly even when you are right, and it can create legal problems that a one star review never would.

Report it as well. Reply and report are separate actions and you should do both.

Things that make it worse

Naming details they did not name. Do not mention their medical condition, their address, what they paid, or that their card declined. Google prohibits posting personal information, and in Australia you have privacy obligations sitting over the top of that.

Arguing point by point. You will win the argument and lose the customer reading it.

"We have no record of you as a customer" as an opener. It reads as dismissive even when it is true. Template three does the same job without the shrug.

Copy-pasting the same reply under every review. People scroll. Identical replies make the good ones look manufactured too.

Offering them something to take it down. More on this next, because it is the one with actual consequences.

Do not pay to make it go away

This is where Australian businesses get themselves in real strife, and it is worth being blunt.

Google's policy prohibits merchants from offering incentives, including payment, discounts or free goods and services, in exchange for posting a review or for revising or removing a negative one. Profiles caught doing this can have reviews stripped, lose the ability to receive new ones, or get suspended.

The ACCC's position runs alongside it. Creating fake or misleading reviews is against the law, and businesses that edit or remove genuine negative reviews to inflate their rating or hide criticism can breach the Australian Consumer Law. The ACCC has also warned about "review removal" outfits that offer to scrub negative reviews, sometimes on a no-win no-fee basis. Meriton was fined three million dollars in 2017 for manipulating its review process.

If a review is genuine, you respond to it. You do not buy it off.

The ACCC's own advice for a review you believe is fake is the sensible path: report it to the platform, and respond publicly in a professional manner to correct the record.

When Google will actually remove one

Reporting is worth doing, but only for the right reasons. Google's own line is that you can report any review, but only reviews that break its policies are eligible for removal, and that you should not report a review just because you disagree with it.

Realistically removable:

• Content from someone with a conflict of interest, such as a current or former employee, a competitor, or a family member
• Reviews not based on a real experience
• Personal or confidential information about someone
• Harassment, hate speech or profanity
• Off-topic content that is not about your business at all

Realistically not removable:

• A harsh but honest opinion
• A bare one star with no text
• A review about something outside your control
• A review you simply think is unfair

To report: find the review on your profile, select the three dots, and follow the prompts. It is anonymous to the reviewer. If it comes back as no violation and you have a strong case, there is an appeal path for a second look.

If someone is threatening bad reviews unless you pay them, that is extortion, not a review problem. Google has a separate reporting path for it, and it is worth reporting to Scamwatch as well.

The thing that actually fixes your rating

You cannot delete your way to four and a half stars. You can dilute your way there.

A one star review sitting among eleven others hurts. The same review sitting among two hundred and eleven barely registers. Steady, ordinary, unincentivised review collection is the only durable answer, and it is boring, which is why almost nobody does it consistently.

Just do not offer anyone anything for it.

---

Sources. Reporting rules and eligibility are from Google Business Profile Help: report inappropriate reviews and Google's prohibited and restricted content policy. Restrictions for fake engagement are covered in Business Profile restrictions for policy violations. Australian obligations are from the ACCC's guidance on online reviews. This is general information, not legal advice. If a review is defamatory or you are being extorted, get proper advice.

Last checked: 25 July 2026.